Why Do Your Employees Work For You?

Just as the customer has expectations around a firm’s brand, so does an employee. While the Customer Value Proposition defines the value of a firm’s products or services to the consumer, the Employee Value Proposition (EVP) is the value — tangible, intangible, and reputational — that an employee receives from an organization in exchange for his or her work.

When we work with organizations on their employee engagement initiatives, we often conduct what we refer to as “engagement summits.” During these summits, we review the results of the company’s employee engagement surveys, discuss recommendations for improvement, and develop action plans. One of the key components of these summits is to discuss the organization’s EVP.

We start by asking organizational leaders, “Why would someone choose to work for you?” All but the most in-touch organizations come back with responses like, “We pay above market,” “We were just voted an employer of choice,” “We have a recognizable name,” or simply, “Because we have a lot of open positions.” Others simply look at each other, laugh uncomfortably, and say “Uhhh…we don’t really know.” Either way, few are able to describe their EVP in any level of detail.

Two companies that know their EVP

We recently worked with two restaurant companies, one a 400-location fast food chain and the other a 150-location upscale chain. The fast food employees, as we learned through surveys and focus groups, found the greatest value in flexible schedules (which allowed them to meet family, school, and social obligations), the ability to associate with friends while on the job, and getting 50% off of once-per-week lunches (a perk that cost about 78 cents per week per employee).

The upscale restaurant workers, in contrast, were engaged by completely different factors: opportunities for growth, development, and advancement; the trust of their managers; community support; and satisfied customers.

The leaders at the fast food chain, understanding their EVP, also understood that most of their workers were young and mobile-device savvy. In order to facilitate scheduling (one of the key drivers of their value proposition), they went to an app-based scheduling system their employees could access from home. They implemented a recruiting referral program that paid employees $100 per referral hired, solving the recruiting problem by bringing networks of friends and family together in the same locations. They expanded their discounted food program to include one meal per four-hour shift. Employee engagement and retention increased significantly.

Article Continues Below

The upscale food chain also looked at its EVP and discovered that the value proposition varied across job descriptions. For example, a large percentage of the chain’s servers (who made up a significant portion of the population) fit into one of two categories: students and single parents. For them, a flexible schedule with sufficient working hours to pay the bills was extremely important. The restaurants accommodated. Restaurant managers and assistant managers, however, valued the opportunity for career development, training, and advancement. For the latter group, they put in place a comprehensive manager training program, which greatly reduced attrition.

Here’s how to know your EVP

Most organizations don’t take the time to review their EVP in detail. Understanding your EVP starts with asking the following questions, but doesn’t end there. We find that many organizations think they know the answers to these questions. However, we also find that many times employees respond differently. This misalignment results in ineffective hiring, disengagement, and attrition.

Do you know your EVP? Start by answering the following four questions (and their corresponding outcome questions). Then, compare your answers with those of your employees to see if you are aligned:

  1. What is our organization’s “brand” (what you are known for by current and potential employees)? What outcomes do you experience because of that brand, and are those the outcomes you want?
  2. Why would someone choose to join your organization (what is the value you propose to future employees)? What would it take to attract that person?
  3. Why would an employee choose to stay at your organization? What would it take to keep that person?
  4. Are there any gaps between what appeals to your employees and what they experience? What would it take to close those gaps?

EVP doesn’t just apply to the organization as a whole. Each company, function, department, plant, and even manager has its own brand. Do you know your EVP?

Tracy Maylett is the Chief Executive Officer of DecisionWise, and co-author of the award-winning book, MAGIC: Five Keys to Unlock the Power of Employee Engagement and The Employee Experience: How to Attract Talent, Retain Top Performers, and Drive Results published by Wiley & Sons. He is responsible for guiding the overall strategy of DecisionWise, as well as leading large-scale change efforts for clients throughout the globe. Tracy has a doctorate in Organization Change from Pepperdine University, an M.B.A. from Brigham Young University, and a B.A. in Education from Utah State University. He has also received certification as a Senior Professional of Human Resources (SPHR), as well as earning SHRM-SCP credentials.


8 Comments on “Why Do Your Employees Work For You?

  1. Q: “Why Do Your Employees Work For You?”
    A: Because you pay them, and there isn’t anything better for them right now.

    1. Pretty succinct Keith. EE really isn’t rocket science except to those who obfuscate the issue to hide how simple it really is. HR likes all the scientific stuff, but in the end the biggest changes come from the top, not the middle. We make tremendous inroads to the employees thinking by simply asking, that is, having the CEO ask them, what do they hate about the company. No science there. But when the changes start occurring every day, the input goes up exponentially. It’s really pretty simple actually. Tracey is absolutely correct about EVP, just provide a safe environment, they’re dying to tell someone what’s wrong, HR? not so much.

      1. Thanks, Jim. IMHO, very little we deal with is “rocket science” but some of our colleagues (particularly the self-proclaimed “recruiting thought leader”- types) like to make it seem that so, to better get lots of money out of their clients/customers.

        “…EVP, just provide a safe environment….”
        Realistically, why should any employee without a “multi-year, no-layoff without substantial severance” contract feel safe? Trust is slowly earned, and easily lost. Unfortunately and accordingly, most employees should release their “Inner CEOs”-
        work to get as much money, training, experience, benies, connections, freebies, swag, etc. as can be squeezed out of the employer, always keep one eye on the way out, and head through it before it comes crashing down.

        1. Exactly. I have four sons and I have taught them to give their employers 100% and every payday the ledger is equal, you don’t owe them anything and believe me they don’t feel like they owe you anything.

  2. When I think of EVP, I think of electronic voice phenomena! Did I watch too much Ghost Hunters as a child? Probably. However, this is a super important KPI. If your employees aren’t on board with your company’s values and goals, you just won’t be productive. Geckoboard hires for culture fit and uses employee NPS to track success: http://bit.ly/2i7mmC8

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *