Pixar and the Secrets of Managing Creative People

If you don’t find Ed Catmull’s Creativity Inc. difficult, you are not reading it right.

The book is an engaging and easy to read story; however its best lessons are subtle and challenging.

Catmull is co-founder of Pixar, the studio behind Toy Story, A Bug’s Life and Monsters Inc. He has a keen interest in simple, well-informed insights. His thoughtful revelation is that simple well-informed insights often lead you astray.

“Trust the process”

Take his story about setting a price for Pixar hardware in the early days of the company. He sought out the advice of experts and they confidently advised setting a high price since you could always reduce it later. That’s simple, clear advice from people with experience.

However, in this case Pixar’s hardware got stuck with the image “good machines, but too expensive.” Even when they reduced the price, the “too expensive” image did not change. That’s one of the reason’s Pixar didn’t become a hardware company — a happy outcome for all of us it as it turns out, but failure to generate revenue from hardware sales almost sunk the company.

Another lesson comes from their mantra for creative work: “Trust the process.”

In the early days of any creative activity the product is ugly. When writers start to develop a story there are elements that just fall flat. The “Trust the process” mantra reassures the creative team they will get through these difficulties if they just keep at it.

Trusting the process is a useful idea, and yet Catmull observed that when the Toy Story 2 team trusted the process they got deeper and deeper into trouble; well into the production, Catmull had to make the expensive (but ultimately brilliant) decision to go back to the drawing board.

Simple insights can be helpful, but just as often they can lead you astray.

Managing creative teams

Of course, there is a ton of good advice about managing creative teams in Creativity Inc. One tip is about the value of postmortems in capturing the lessons learned after a film has been made.

Catmull warns us that while everyone agrees that postmortems are a good idea, people naturally resist doing them, and may fall into exchanging polite comments rather than raise uncomfortable issues. You need the postmortem process, but more than that you need a mindset that makes sure the process is doing what it is meant to do.

Catmull was trained as a scientist and that perspective shines through the book. Perhaps his biggest contribution to management thinking is his notion of “The Hidden.” That’s the idea that even when we try to be attentive, there will be important issues facing the organization that we will be blind to.

Article Continues Below

He tells the story of the Toy Story production where, despite leadership’s vigorous efforts to create an open and egalitarian culture the production managers felt they were treated like second class citizens. Leadership had no idea production managers felt this way, even thought– and thesis  important — they were looking for exactly this kind of issue.

You have to manage in the knowledge that important issues will always be hidden from you. Catmull says “If you don’t try to uncover what is unseen, and understand its nature, you will be ill-prepared to lead.”

The importance of candor – from everyone

To the extent that Catmull does have a mantra he fully trusts, it is that we need candor from everyone on the team. Big, creative projects require the application of an enormous amount of intelligence, and you can’t access that intelligence unless everyone is contributing.

It is hard to be honest; it can hurt feelings (which is especially a concern if the person with hurt feelings is your boss). Finding ways to engender candor is one of Pixar’s great victories as an organization.

One final fact struck me: At one point, Catmull mentions that he questioned whether he was cut out to be a CEO. All the other CEOs he knew were brash and confident. He, like any good scientist, was full of questions and doubt.

Catmull didn’t fit the standard mold of a leader yet he has proven to be an extremely effective one. So let’s consider this hypothesis: maybe the standard mold is a poor one.

If we in HR continue to hire brash, confident leaders who believe in simple mantras then maybe we are selecting exactly the wrong sort of person to lead in today’s world.

David Creelman, CEO of Creelman Research, is a globally recognized thinker on people analytics and talent management. Some of his more interesting projects included:

  • Conducted workshops around the world on the practical aspects of people analytics
  • Took business leaders from Japan’s Recruit Co. on a tour of US tech companies (Recruit eventually bought Indeed.com for $1 billion)
  • Studied the relationship between Boards and HR (won Walker Award)
  • Spoke at the World Bank in Paris on HR reporting
  • Co-authored Lead the Work: Navigating a world beyond employment with John Boudreau and Ravin Jesuthasan. The book was endorsed by the CHROs of IBM, LinkedIn and Starbucks.
  • Worked with Dr. Wanda Wallace on “Leading when you are not the expert” which topped the “Most Popular List” on the Harvard Business Review’s blog.
  • Worked with Dr. Henry Mintzberg on peer coaching, David’s learning modules are among the most popular topics.

Currently David is helping organizations to get on-track with people analytics.

This work led to him being made a Fellow for the Centre of Evidence-based Management (Netherlands) for his contributions to the field.



1 Comment on “Pixar and the Secrets of Managing Creative People

  1. One of the best articles I’ve ever read on decision making is on the Cynefin (pronounced ku-nev-in) Framework which distinguishes between making decisions in a simple environment to making decisions in complex or complicated environments. Plus, the framework provides insight on how to stay out of chaos.

    Snowden and Boone (2007) claimed that we consult experts when we feel a situation is complicated (as Catmull did with hardware pricing). Snowden and Boone suggested we allow non-experts to challenge the experts. Snowden and Boone also argued that best practices (seems similar to “trust the process”) are of value only in simple situations. Most often, we are challenged to move beyond best practice and beyond expert analysis (as we try to minimize chaos!). Snowden and Boone advised that in a complex situation where there are no right answers, leaders need to ask questions and be patient enough to watch a path emerge. This advice supports Catmull’s conclusion of trying to uncover the unseen and understand it. Your readers might enjoy the article by Snowden and Boone: A leader’s framework for decision making.

    David, as always, enjoyed your fresh perspective and clear focus. A brash, confident leader who sticks to simple mantras isn’t our best choice in today’s complex environment.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *