Four Steps to Make Sure You Get Accurate Criminal Background Checks

Illustration by

After months of searching, you finally found the perfect candidate for your (insert job here) role.

This guy or gal has everything you’re looking for: great experience, sterling references, and a personality that fits well within your organization. Let’s face it — they are the bee’s knees.

Now, the only thing that has stopped you from making an offer is waiting for you on your desk — the background check results.

You furiously scan the document to make sure there are no red flags: verified education and employment  … check, stellar driving record  … check, substance abuse test came back clean … check. But wait. No, this can’t be happening. Your best candidate is a registered sex offender?

Inaccurate results can cause a BIG problem

A similar story played out in 2010 with a candidate named Samuel Jackson (no not that Samuel Jackson, but keep reading). Jackson was denied employment because his background check revealed that he was in fact, a registered sex offender. There was only one problem, our Samuel Jackson was a white 27-year-old male. Sam the Sex Offender was a middle-aged black man.

Employers and background screening companies are under a microscope more than ever when it comes to criminal background checks, and with good reason. Candidates expect that the results of their background check will be accurate.

At a minimum, inaccurate results create a negative candidate experience and reflect poorly on the employer. And all too commonly these days, these inaccurate results lead to both the employer and background screening company being sued.

Article Continues Below

Background screening companies and by extension, the employers they represent have the responsibility of ensuring maximum possible accuracy under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (there is actually an ugly loophole to this, but don’t get me started). So how do you take all possible steps to ensure accuracy?

4 steps to help ensure background screening accuracy

Here are four imperatives to ensure your background screening company is committed to accuracy:

  1. Ensure they are going to the best possible source when it comes to identifying criminal records. The best way to get up to speed on this is to download our white paper: Time for a Wake Up Call: Are Your Criminal Background Checks Giving You a False Sense of Security?
  2. Don’t accept records where the identifiers have not been matched. At a minimum, two identifiers should be used to confirm the authenticity of a record: the candidate’s name and date of birth, social security number or address. If the identifiers haven’t been confirmed, you’re playing with fire, scarecrow.
  3. Demand that any record that is less than clear is verified with the court before it is reported. You don’t want to make a hiring decision based on information you don’t understand.
  4. Consider using a provider that is accredited by the National Association of Professional Background Screeners. Less than 2 percent are actually accredited and with good reason — the process isn’t for the faint of heart. (For more information on accreditation, read our post, The Stats Don’t Lie: Why Should You Care About Employment Background Screening Accreditation?)

Candidates and employers should demand accuracy when it comes to employment background checks and it is incumbent upon all of us to make sure that we are doing everything possible to live up to these expectations.

This was originally published on the EmployeeScreen IQ blog.


1 Comment on “Four Steps to Make Sure You Get Accurate Criminal Background Checks

  1. No one seems to question the results they get because people just accept whatever “bad” information they are given is TRUE. People always believe the worst and no one is ever the wiser because people are unaware that someone has run a background check on them and it “silently” ruins their reputation. This ENTIRE Scam should be banned. If people don’t have access to the persons SSN then these companies can sell and attach any derogatory information that may be affiliated with ANYONE with a similar name. I almost lost my Town Home Lease because of a ‘So called Reputable” and popular online report. I will Never do that again. People who are suspicious of another person or just “NOSY” buy yearly subscriptions to these fake reports and then so many people are damaged. You can only get an accurate Check if you have a SSN and it is done through a Law Enforcement agency. I wish people would be more responsible but unfortunately there will always be those NOSY Neighbors who love to find out the “Goods” on someone and if you are looking for the “BAD” They will sell it to you. Just remember, it is most certainly NOT the truth. Ultimately you will be the one made to look bad when you go spreading the tales.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *