Do Careers Pay a Price for Flexibility on the Job?

Not so long ago, a request for flexibility carried with it stigma and a hit to one’s career.

Today flex work is in the mainstream, and millions do it without apparent consequence.

Or do they?

Lisa Leslie and Colleen Manchester have thrown some cold water on this reassuring narrative. In a creative study (Flexible Work Practices: A Source of Career Premiums or Penalties?), these two University of Minnesota Carlson School of Management professors combined surveys of users and managers of those on flexible schedules with lab-based simulations to see if employees were likely to pay a career price for using flexible schedules.

It’ all about personal vs. productivity

The answer: it depends on your motivation. They found that managers tend to reward those who flex for productivity reasons and penalize those with requests for personal reasons. (I excerpt and summarize their findings in my FlexBulletin #75)

If they are right, and career penalties are an unintended consequence of a very desirable practice, how has this happened? And what can be done about it?

I would offer a simple explanation. Gains for the company don’t automatically translate into gains for the manager or credit for the employee. It comes down to the “business case.” The rapid diffusion of flexibility has been fueled by a business case heavy on WIIFC — What’s In It For the Company? PowerPoints abound with claims of recruitment, retention, real estate savings, productivity, business continuity. All true, but all enterprise gains.

The other two WIIFMs are far less compelling. The question What’s In It For the Manager? should be answered in collaborative sessions with the employee focused on how a different way of working could add operational value. But these are far less common than they should be. And productivity gains that might be realized and rewarded end up as random in both execution and impact.

All too often, the reason DOES matter

The employee is the initiator of most flex and always has an answer to the classic WIFFM – What’s in It For Me? Unfortunately, more often than not that answer is a personal one. While great benefits of flexible schedules might accrue to both company and manager, and the employee might ultimately generate them, the typical manager is looking for “signals of commitment.”

Absent a deliberate process, it is the commitment to personal life that stands out to managers and others who decide on rewards, development and advancement. If the research is correct, leading with a personal reason rather than a productivity plan is a formula for career slowdown.

Article Continues Below

What can be done to address this problem? While the politically correct thing to say on the path to flexibility these days is that “the reason doesn’t matter,” it is far too often all that matters.

For better or worse, fair or unfair, employees who want to avoid any career penalties need to lead their requests with productivity rather than the personal. And their companies and managers need to insist and assist on this.

It needs to be more than just a personal payoff

The emphasis needs to be on WIIFU – What’s In It For Us? True collaboration is imperative in the interest of schedules that maximize business outcomes and employee satisfaction.

Yet of the thousands of employee flexibility proposals I have read, 95 percent focus on personal payoff and the rest on vague business gains. If I were the manager reviewing these “business proposals,” I’d send them back for revision or want to sit down and negotiate a better deal.

But managers almost never do these things. They seem to sign off on any proposal and then harbor who knows what opinion of the employee’s commitment. As the study suggests, employees are by default setting themselves up for the penalties that tend to attach to personal life requests. And most managers collude.

Without strong expectations for business-beneficial collaboration, rigorous training and measurable processes, that won’t change. And everyone will pay an unnecessary price.

Paul Rupert has collaborated with colleagues, clients and business leaders to embed flexibility in the workplace for the past 40 years. His consulting firm, Washington, DC-based Rupert & Company, has provided dozens of major employers with innovative strategies, training and online tools to build the flexibility the market will bear. Paul has played a leading role in developing flexibility systems in companies ranging from Aetna and AOL to Wal-Mart and Xerox, and is the architect of the Co Scheduling approach. Contact him at


2 Comments on “Do Careers Pay a Price for Flexibility on the Job?

  1. While flexwork is becoming mainstream and more businesses are getting on board by implementing alternative work options, keep in mind this is only just the beginning. In the past, flexibility was primarily focused on women and specifically working mothers. However, the conversation is now shifting to accommodate men. This article shines a light on both how far we’ve come and how much further we must go to change society’s outlook on work-life alignment. Yes, increased productivity is a huge benefit of flexibility, but at the same time it is unfortunate that many managers are tending to reward those who flex for productivity reasons while penalizing those who flex for personal/family reasons. Whatever the reason for seeking flexwork options, there is one simple truth—a healthy and happy employee leads to a more engaged and productive employee, and that should be what matters most. -Allison O’Kelly, founder/CEO Mom Corps

    1. Hi, Allison — I’m a fan of the good work you do to expand flexible options. I agree on the progress made, and the distance to go. Whether managers should lean toward the productivity metric in their decisions, or not, likely many thousands do. My takeaway from this research is that flex does make people more engaged and productive — and they would be wise to frame their requests in terms of the enhanced productivity it creates. Put simply: to get ahead, lead with the productive, not personal reasons. Or enjoy the personal value, but celebrate value added.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *